We Were Never Actually Together

Song Meaning

The lyrics immediately plunge into a darkly comedic narrative of post-breakup obsession. The narrator claims to have "moved on" from Jake Gyllenhaal, yet is actively engaged in voodoo and making incessant calls. This opening establishes a character deeply mired in denial and unsettling fixation. Central to the lyrics is the narrator's profound delusion, repeatedly insisting, "We were never ever ever actually together." This denial is immediately undermined by a torrent of fabricated, extreme shared memories—from "smoking crack together" to "had sex with a tree." The internal conflict is explicitly acknowledged, with one side of the narrator getting "the hint" while the other is "ogidy, ogidy, ogidy," clearly winning the internal battle. The craft here masterfully blends the absurd with the genuinely disturbing. The narrator's descent into fantasy is punctuated by bizarre, almost childlike details, like using a "hipster voodoo doll" or claiming "My stuffed animals totally remember it." This juxtaposition of extreme violence and delusion with mundane or childish elements—like taking "Flintstones" pills or needing "new batteries" for a gagged mother—creates a uniquely unsettling tone, making the listener question the line between imagined and actual horror. As the lyrics escalate, the narrator fully embraces a "Gollum" persona, complete with homicidal ideation towards "Your mom" and a chilling focus on a trivial "sweater." The final threat, "He will be dismembered / My precious," solidifies the terrifying scope of this unchecked obsession. The effectiveness lies in how the lyrics use pop culture references and dark humor to paint a portrait of a mind unraveling, leaving a lingering sense of unease about what is real within this twisted narrative.