Which Will (2017)

Song Meaning

The lyrics present a stark, almost desperate plea for a choice to be made. The repeated question, "Which will you go for?" and its variations, establishes a central tension: the narrator is caught in a state of indecision, waiting for someone else to commit. The imagery of "stars above" suggests a vast, perhaps overwhelming, array of possibilities, making the singular choice even more critical and difficult. The core conflict lies in the narrator's unchosen status. They are not the one being pursued or selected, but rather the observer of a selection process that excludes them. The questions escalate from general choices like love and answering calls to more personal ones: "Which will you choose now / If you won't choose mine?" and "Which will you take now / If you won't take me?" This shift highlights the narrator's growing anxiety and the personal stakes involved. The most striking aspect of the craft is the relentless repetition of "Which will you..." This structure creates a hypnotic, almost pleading rhythm, emphasizing the narrator's powerlessness and their fixation on the other person's decision-making. The simplicity of the language, combined with the directness of the questions, amplifies the raw emotion. The chorus, a simple "Tell me now / Which will you love the best?" acts as a desperate summation of the verses' anxieties. This lyrical approach is effective because it mirrors the agonizing feeling of being on the outside of a crucial decision. The narrator's vulnerability is palpable, not through grand declarations, but through the simple, repeated act of questioning. The listener is drawn into this limbo, feeling the weight of the unspoken choice and the pain of potential rejection.