Song Meaning
The lyrics immediately cast a shadow of hypocrisy and accusation. The speaker points out the irony of a "mistress" who, despite her own perceived transgressions ("follow whores"), still holds the subject accountable. It's a sharp observation about how judgment can come from unexpected, even compromised, sources. The phrasing "still taxeth you" suggests a persistent, almost burdensome demand for reckoning.
The central tension lies in this peculiar form of confession and accusation. The mistress acknowledges her own questionable behavior, yet this admission doesn't absolve the subject; instead, it seems to empower her to continue her critique. The narrator finds this dynamic "strange," highlighting the uncomfortable truth that even those with flaws can possess a valid, albeit uncomfortable, perspective. The truth of the accusation is acknowledged, adding a layer of complexity to the mistress's position.
The effectiveness here hinges on the biting, almost archaic language that lends a timeless quality to the interpersonal drama. The word "taxeth" is particularly striking, framing the mistress's demands not just as criticism but as a form of imposition or debt being collected. This specific word choice elevates the interaction beyond simple nagging into something more formal and inescapable, underscoring the weight of the subject's perceived failures.