Song Meaning
This lyric paints a tender scene of a child being soothed by a gentle lullaby. The dominant tone is one of profound peace and almost divine comfort, suggesting the lullaby possesses a power beyond ordinary music. The narrator emphasizes the unparalleled sweetness of this song, positioning it as superior to any professional musician's performance.
An interesting contrast emerges when the nightingale's song is introduced. While typically associated with beautiful birdsong, here it's described as "hoarse and nought thereto," implying it's inferior and irrelevant compared to the child's lullaby. This comparison elevates the lullaby's magic, making it seem like a singular, perfect sound.
The core of the lyric lies in its assertion of the lullaby's unique value. The final lines deliver a strong moral judgment: "Whoso attendeth to her song / And leaveth the first then doth he wrong." This suggests that choosing any other music over this specific, deeply comforting melody is a mistake, a kind of spiritual or emotional error.
This piece is effective because it grounds an abstract idea of perfect comfort in a concrete, relatable action: lulling a child to sleep. The simple, direct language and the clear hierarchy of musical value create a powerful, almost sacred feeling around the lullaby. It's a quiet testament to the profound impact of a specific, loving sound.