Song Meaning
The lyrics open with a direct, almost disbelieving address: "What, Bichyat, is that you, like?" This sets a tone of surprise and familiarity, immediately establishing a conversation with someone the speaker knows, or at least recognizes. The speaker claims loyalty, stating they've never burned any of the addressee's CDs, but then immediately contradicts this by admitting to burning everyone else's. This suggests a special, perhaps even possessive, admiration for the addressee's original work, framing it as something precious and unique.
The core tension arises from a perceived disconnect between the addressee's public persona and the speaker's memory or understanding of them. The speaker recounts rumors about the addressee's life – returning to religion, going a bit crazy, wearing a kippah, past drug use – painting a picture of transformation or instability. This contrasts sharply with the speaker's insistence on a shared past, where they claim to have been a formative influence, teaching the addressee "by candlelight" about "sound, word, sky and sand." This creates a conflict between the present, rumored version of the artist and the speaker's self-proclaimed role in their artistic genesis.
A striking element is the harsh critique of the addressee's physical presence versus their televised image. "On TV you look huge," the speaker observes, but in reality, they are "so short" and "so thin." This jarring contrast highlights a disillusionment, a feeling that the larger-than-life persona doesn't match the actual person. The speaker then pivots to praise the addressee's brother, Avi, calling him "amazing" and noting that "everyone at our house loves" him, subtly diminishing the addressee by comparison and suggesting a preference for a different family member.
Ultimately, the lyrics' effectiveness stems from this blend of fan adoration and blunt, almost cruel, reality checks. The repeated question, "What, Bichyat, is that you, like?" underscores a profound sense of bewilderment and disappointment. The speaker seems to be grappling with an artist who has changed, whose public image is at odds with their past, and whose current form doesn't live up to the speaker's idealized memory or expectations. The final pleas to sing in Greek, make "tons of money," and "come down to the people" reveal a desire for a specific kind of commercial success and authenticity that the speaker feels the addressee is missing, further emphasizing the gap between who the artist is and who the speaker wishes them to be.