What Would You Do

Song Meaning

These lyrics plunge into a series of confrontational hypotheticals, asking what another person would do in extreme situations of love, violence, and sex. The speaker immediately answers for themselves, consistently embracing the identity of a "sinner." It's a raw, direct exploration of intense human impulses. A central tension emerges between the speaker's willingness to "fall like a sinner" and their aversion to "fall in lose." This unusual phrasing, "fall in lose," suggests a profound fear of being lost or losing something essential, contrasting sharply with the active choice to engage in what might be considered sin. It implies a preference for deliberate transgression over a passive state of defeat or emptiness. The craft here is relentless. The lyrics build intensity through a repeated chorus structure, escalating from love to kill to fuck, each time reaffirming the speaker's "sinner" identity. The shift from "I knew that I'd fall" to "I know that I fuck" in the final chorus marks a hardening of resolve, culminating in the visceral declaration, "I know that I'd fuck you until you're blue." This final image is both explicit and almost violently passionate. Ultimately, these lyrics hit hard because they refuse to flinch. They lay bare a defiant self-acceptance, where the speaker's identity as a "sinner" is not a source of shame but a chosen path, preferable to the ambiguous dread of "lose." The direct language and escalating scenarios create a powerful, unforgettable statement about desire, consequence, and self-definition.