Song Meaning
This madrigal opens with a seemingly simple declaration of affection: the narrator's "bonny lass" smiles, and this smile captivates his heart. The repeated "Fa la la" interjections, a common feature of madrigals, create a light, almost playful atmosphere that contrasts with the intense emotions described. It sets up an immediate tension between outward appearance and inner feeling.
The core conflict arises from the narrator's paradoxical plea: "Smile less, dear love, therefore / And you shall love me more." He acknowledges her smile "beguiles" his heart and her eyes "burneth" him, suggesting that her beauty and charm are almost too much to bear. He desires her affection, yet her very allure, expressed through her smile and gaze, causes him pain and threatens to consume him.
The most striking aspect is the narrator's desperate request for her to suppress her own beauty. He asks her to "call in their light," referring to her eyes, because "else you burn me quite!" This isn't a typical love song where the admirer basks in the beloved's radiance. Instead, the narrator seems overwhelmed, finding her powerful charm a source of torment rather than joy, a clever subversion of romantic tropes.
This lyrical conceit is effective because it taps into a relatable, if exaggerated, feeling of being overwhelmed by someone's presence. The contrast between the cheerful "Fa la la" and the narrator's near-distress creates a sophisticated emotional landscape. It suggests that intense attraction can be a double-edged sword, capable of both delight and deep, burning discomfort.
View Artist