Song Meaning
The lyrics paint a stark picture of Time as a thief, not a benevolent force. The narrator observes Time systematically draining a person's vitality, starting with the "light" in her eyes and progressing to her "lily tincts and rose"—her youthful bloom and spirit. This theft is presented as a gradual, almost imperceptible process, so subtle that its absence is only noticed "by-and-by." The imagery of light being stolen and colors fading creates a somber, almost mournful tone, emphasizing the irreversible nature of this loss.
The central tension arises from the narrator's confrontation with Time. Initially, the narrator questions Time's actions, assuming a possessive motive: "Hoard these her sweets—?" This assumption reveals a human tendency to seek purpose or reward in loss. Time's response, however, is chillingly indifferent. It claims no pleasure in the stolen "sweets" and casually dismisses them as being "carelessly away" by "Time throw / Them carelessly away." This highlights a profound disconnect between human perception of value and Time's seemingly arbitrary destructive power.
The most striking aspect of the craft is the dialogue where Time reveals its own perceived lack of agency or understanding regarding human concepts like cruelty. When the narrator labels Time's actions as "cruelty," Time expresses genuine surprise, stating, "The thought is new to me." This is a profound twist: Time, the agent of decay and loss, claims to be taught by mortals. The final lines, "Forsooth, though I men's master be, / Theirs is the teaching mind!" suggest that while Time dictates the physical passage of moments and the inevitable aging process, it is humanity's interpretation, its labeling of these events as cruel or sad, that gives them their emotional weight. Time is the mechanism, but humanity provides the meaning.
This lyrical construction is effective because it reframes a universal experience—aging and loss—through an unexpected philosophical lens. By personifying Time and then revealing its apparent ignorance of human suffering, the lyrics force a re-evaluation of our relationship with mortality. The narrator's initial observation of theft transforms into a contemplation of how human consciousness imbues natural processes with emotional significance. The power isn't in Time's actions, but in our perception and our capacity to label those actions as cruel, thereby teaching Time, in a sense, the very concept of suffering.
View Artist