Song Meaning
This track frames a perceived rivalry between XTC and Adam Ant as a battle of artistic philosophies. The lyrics present a clear dichotomy: XTC represents "content" and "Beatle-based pop," while Adam Ant embodies "form" and "new romantic" aesthetics. It’s pitched as a fight for dominance in the rock and roll landscape, though the song immediately questions the validity of this conflict, stating "There is no right or wrong."
The central tension lies in this manufactured competition and the uncertainty of its outcome. The chorus repeatedly declares "Just when you think it's finished / With XTC on top," only for Adam Ant's "Antmusic" to "Flies back up the charts." This cyclical narrative suggests that neither artist can definitively claim victory, highlighting the ephemeral nature of chart success and critical favor. The narrator admits, "I can't tell you why," further emphasizing the subjective and perhaps arbitrary nature of this artistic feud.
The most striking aspect of the writing is its meta-commentary on music criticism and fan perception. By pitting two distinct styles against each other, the lyrics expose how audiences and critics often create narratives of conflict where none may truly exist. The line "History will decide" serves as a resigned shrug, acknowledging that ultimate judgment is out of the artists' and narrator's hands. The inclusion of "Even the singer from Bow Wow Wow / Can't make up her mind" humorously underscores this indecision and the difficulty in definitively crowning a winner.
Ultimately, the effectiveness of these lyrics stems from their ability to dissect the very act of comparing artists. The song doesn't just present a rivalry; it comments on the impulse to create one, using the specific examples of XTC and Adam Ant to illustrate a broader point about artistic value. The repeated assertion that "There is no right or wrong" leaves the listener contemplating the subjective nature of taste and the futility of declaring one artistic approach superior to another.
View Artist