Song Meaning
The lyrics paint a stark picture of something pervasive and beautiful that ultimately becomes destructive. Initially, it's described as being "in the air" and "covering everything," a force that transforms trees into "diamond things." This imagery suggests a moment of breathtaking, almost magical change, where the ordinary is rendered extraordinary and precious.
However, this beauty carries a heavy price. The same force that creates dazzling "diamond things" also "weighs too much" and "breaks everything." This creates a central tension: the allure of transformation versus the inevitable consequence of destruction. The repetition of "It breaks everything" hammers home the destructive nature of this overwhelming force.
The most striking element is the contrast between the destructive weight and the repeated plea, "We could both be naked now and innocent." This phrase, appearing twice in the chorus, suggests a desire to return to a state of purity and vulnerability, free from the burden that "breaks everything." It implies that shedding the external covering, whatever it may be, is the only way to escape the crushing weight and reclaim innocence.
This juxtaposition makes the lyrics so potent. The beautiful, crystalline imagery of ice-covered branches is undercut by the harsh reality of their breaking point. The yearning for an innocent, unburdened state highlights the suffocating effect of whatever "it" represents, making the listener feel the pressure and the desperate desire for release.