Song Meaning
The narrator is reaching out, desperate for a sign of happiness from someone who seems emotionally distant. There's a clear plea for connection, offering unconditional support: "there's nothin' I won't do." Yet, this desire is met with confusion and a strange, almost detached interaction, as the other person "make[s] no sense at all." The narrator's focus on the other person's smile and hygiene, specifically brushing teeth, creates an odd intimacy.
This fixation on dental care becomes a peculiar metaphor for emotional openness. The narrator admires the other person's habit, "always liked the way you brush three times a day," seeing it as a sign of self-care and perhaps a controlled exterior. When the narrator compliments the smile, the response is a deflection, a command to "go and brush mine too," suggesting the other person is unwilling to reciprocate vulnerability or accept genuine affection. It’s a subtle push-and-pull where affection is met with a demand for conformity.
The lyrics pivot sharply in the third stanza, revealing a growing frustration. The narrator offers an invitation to "talk it through" and "exercise your smile," but the underlying sentiment shifts. The narrator admits, "'Cause I've got so many things I'd rather do," culminating in the stark declaration, "And I'd like to go and do them without you." This reveals the initial outreach was perhaps more out of obligation or a desire for a fleeting positive interaction than deep-seated affection.
The final stanza circles back to the theme of cleanliness and emotional distance. The other person reappears, offering vague promises: "you'd be anything for me." However, the narrator's response is guarded, a request to "use your hanky please" and a reiteration of wanting to "keep mine clean." This suggests a desire to maintain emotional boundaries, a protective measure against the other person's perceived emotional messiness or insincerity, ultimately highlighting a relationship stuck in a cycle of superficiality and unmet expectations.