Song Meaning
The narrator arrives in Oil City with a specific, perhaps transactional, purpose related to "Hershey and oil." This journey is framed as a contrast to his usual "world traveling and roaming," suggesting a deliberate, focused mission. He encounters a "fair maiden" whose initial reaction is one of apprehension, pulling up her garments to avoid soiling them, which sets up a peculiar juxtaposition with the narrator's immediate, aggressive action: "I out with old Phoenix went boring for oil."
The core of the lyrics lies in a striking double entendre, blending the literal act of drilling for oil with a thinly veiled sexual encounter. The maiden's fear of soiling herself is quickly followed by the narrator's "boring" action, and the subsequent "oil from my auger, so freely did pour" directly mirrors the physical response of the maiden, who "wiggled her ass, and looked up and smiled." This is further cemented by her suggestive command: "Bear down on your auger, or I know you struck oil."
The craft here is in the relentless, almost crude, application of the oil drilling metaphor to a sexual act. Phrases like "six inches or more" and "auger machinery got to fire" maintain the industrial imagery while describing escalating intimacy. The narrative progresses from a hesitant encounter to a prolonged, intense period of "a week or ten days," where the "machinery" itself becomes overheated, implying a feverish, perhaps unsustainable, passion.
This lyrical approach is effective because it uses a singular, unexpected metaphor to create a sense of both crude humor and a surprisingly raw depiction of physical connection. The consistent, almost obsessive, return to the "boring for oil" motif transforms a potentially awkward encounter into a narrative driven by a singular, driving force, leaving the listener with a vivid, if somewhat blunt, image of intense physical engagement.