Song Meaning
This track paints a picture of a love that began with immediate certainty, a feeling so profound it felt like the antidote to past sorrow. The narrator recalls a powerful connection, a "love in September," that felt destined from the very beginning. This initial intensity, however, is juxtaposed with the pain of its ending, suggesting a complex emotional landscape where profound joy and deep hurt coexist.
The central tension arises from the unexpected heartbreak that followed such a promising start. The lyrics reveal a sense of disbelief, questioning how such a deep connection could lead to pain, specifically noting, "How could we know we were hurt our feeling so." The eventual breakup, described as a moment of profound sadness when the other person declared "it's over," underscores the contrast between the initial hope and the eventual reality.
The recurring phrase "Still our very first love lingers" acts as a powerful anchor, emphasizing the enduring impact of this September romance despite the pain. The chorus, "Love in September / Is love for ever more," becomes a poignant, almost defiant, declaration. It suggests that while the relationship may have ended, the significance and memory of that first love remain eternal, transcending the actual duration of the relationship.
This lyrical construction is effective because it taps into the universal experience of first love's indelible mark. The contrast between the initial certainty and the eventual sorrow creates a relatable narrative of youthful idealism meeting harsh reality. The persistent echo of "lingers" and the chorus's hopeful, albeit bittersweet, assertion of permanence make the memory of this September love feel both deeply personal and widely resonant.