Song Meaning
The lyrics paint a picture of profound disappointment and a sense of being adrift, symbolized by the "southern cross" that is "full of holes." This isn't a guiding star, but something broken and unreliable. The imagery of a "shark that never shows / Right until it's everywhere" evokes a sense of impending, unseen danger or a threat that suddenly becomes overwhelming, mirroring the narrator's struggle to "make it alright." The repeated, desperate question, "So what do I do?" underscores a feeling of helplessness and a lack of direction.
The central tension arises from betrayal and abandonment, both by a metaphorical "southern cross" and by friends who "never show / Right when you need them more." The narrator expresses a deep frustration with those who were expected to be reliable but proved otherwise, leaving them to face overwhelming circumstances alone. The contrast between the narrator's effort to "make it alright" and the failure of others to reciprocate or even be present highlights a profound sense of isolation.
A striking element is the repetition of "Alright!" juxtaposed with the overwhelming sense of things being not alright at all. This exclamation, delivered with increasing desperation, seems less a statement of success and more a plea or a forced affirmation against mounting evidence to the contrary. The "southern cross" itself, a celestial navigation tool, being "full of holes" and "frozen and over" is a potent metaphor for lost guidance and a frozen emotional state, intensifying the feeling of being lost.
Ultimately, the effectiveness of these lyrics lies in their raw portrayal of disillusionment and the quiet panic of facing overwhelming problems without support. The simple, direct language and the insistent questioning create an intimate portrait of someone grappling with the collapse of their support systems and their own faltering attempts to maintain control. The repeated "Alright!" acts as a desperate, almost involuntary reflex against the encroaching darkness, making the narrator's plight feel acutely personal and deeply felt.