Nevertheless I’m in Love with You - Live at Red Hill

Song Meaning

The narrator lays out a stark dichotomy of potential outcomes, acknowledging the inherent risks in their current emotional state. They admit to a profound uncertainty about their own nature and the future, oscillating between strength and weakness, victory and defeat. This self-awareness of potential failure, even the prospect of 'crying the blues,' sets a somber stage for the central declaration. The core tension arises from the narrator's clear-eyed recognition of the 'terrible chances' they are taking in love. They understand that this path might lead to a 'heart that is breaking,' and that they could end up with 'lots more than I'll get.' This isn't a naive infatuation; it's a conscious choice made despite foreknowledge of potential pain and imbalance. The repeated phrase 'Nevertheless I'm in love with you' acts as an anchor against the tide of doubt. It’s a defiant affirmation, a refusal to let potential negative consequences dictate their feelings. The structure hammers this home, presenting a list of 'maybes' only to cut through them with the unwavering certainty of their love, even as the pre-chorus warns of a 'breaking, breaking' heart. This lyrical approach resonates because it captures the complex reality of deep affection. It’s not about ignoring the risks, but about choosing to love anyway, acknowledging the vulnerability and potential for hurt. The power lies in this brave, almost stubborn, commitment to love despite the overwhelming odds and the narrator’s own admitted weaknesses.