Song Meaning
The lyrics present a delicate, almost hesitant dance between two individuals, Nellie and Emile, each observing the other from a distance. Nellie imagines a serene life by the ocean, a stark contrast to her current state of nervous anticipation, likening herself to a "school girl" waiting for a dance. This internal fantasy highlights a yearning for peace and perhaps a different existence.
Emile, on the other hand, focuses on Nellie's presence, seeing her as the "young and smilin'" figure he's longed for, climbing his metaphorical "hill." He perceives her as desirable, with "officers and doctors" likely pursuing her, suggesting she has options. This creates an immediate tension: Nellie's internal world of quiet longing versus Emile's outward perception of her desirability and his own hopeful approach.
The core of the lyrics lies in their mutual, yet separate, anxieties about connection. Nellie sees their differences – "cultured Frenchman" versus "little hick" – as a barrier, fearing she would "bore him." Emile, conversely, is consumed by the uncertainty of her response, asking himself, "What will be her answer?" This parallel internal monologue, framed as twin soliloquies, captures the vulnerability of potential romance.
The effectiveness of these lyrics stems from their simple, direct language that mirrors the tentative nature of their feelings. The repeated "Wonder how I'd feel" and "Wonder why I feel" from Nellie, juxtaposed with Emile's direct questions of "Can I ask her now?" and "Do I have a chance?", perfectly encapsulate the nervous energy of two people on the cusp of something, each lost in their own hopeful, yet fearful, thoughts.