Song Meaning
Marc Almond's live rendition of "Tenderness is a Weakness" cuts straight to the bone of emotional self-preservation. It's a stark declaration from someone who's learned, likely through hard experience, that vulnerability is a liability. The opening lines paint a picture of a man isolated, a prisoner of his own guarded nature, seeking solace, paradoxically, in another's sorrow. The repeated commands to "throw him away" and "leave him alone" suggest a brutal severing, a rejection of any lingering attachment to this fragile, emotionally needy figure. This isn't just heartbreak; it's a calculated act of self-defense. The singer recognizes the danger in such openness.
The core of the song lies in the acknowledgement of a deliberate choice: to extinguish the "flame" in his eyes and cling to mystery. This isn't about romantic allure; it's about control. By obscuring his true self, he maintains a fortress against potential hurt. The line "secrets that make up me" hints at a complex inner world, deliberately shielded from outside view. This manufactured persona, a blend of "what's real and fantasy," becomes his armor. It's a defense mechanism against the perceived threat of genuine connection.
The chorus drives home the central theme. "Tenderness is a weakness; it tears down your fortresses." It's a ruthless assessment, devoid of sentimentality. Tenderness, in this worldview, isn't a virtue but a vulnerability, an "easy access" point for exploitation or pain. The final lines seal the sentiment with a chilling clarity: tenderness makes you vulnerable to "that sick, dangerous feeling we all know as love." It's a bleak but honest portrayal of someone who equates love with danger, choosing self-protection over the potential for intimacy. Almond's delivery, particularly in a live setting, likely amplifies the raw, almost defiant quality of this sentiment.