Song Meaning
This lyric paints a picture of a lover whose beloved is easily swayed by gossip, leading to dramatic outbursts. The narrator expresses frustration that any mention of another suitor immediately ignites his lady's temper and accusations of superficial affection. He feels misunderstood, insisting his love is genuine and profound, unlike the "fashion" he believes men typically pursue.
The central tension lies in the narrator's struggle to prove his sincerity against his lover's volatile reactions, which are apparently triggered by external rumors. He laments that her "humour" shifts so readily, and her passionate declarations that "You men love but for fashion" seem to dismiss his own deep feelings. This creates a cycle of perceived betrayal and defensive protestation.
The most striking element is the stark contrast between the narrator's earnest plea and the lady's quick-tempered, generalized accusations. The repeated "Ah me!" and "alas" underscore his weariness and sorrow, while the direct address "be wary / For women be contrary" reveals a resigned, almost cynical, conclusion about the nature of love and his particular beloved.
Ultimately, the effectiveness of these lyrics stems from their concise portrayal of a specific, relatable romantic conflict. The narrator's vulnerability and his lover's dramatic, rumor-fueled jealousy create a vivid snapshot of a relationship under strain, highlighting the difficulty of maintaining trust when external voices hold sway.
View Artist