Song Meaning
The lyrics paint a picture of a relationship's abrupt and emotionally hollow end. The narrator recalls a past where both partners were deeply affected by setbacks, noting "little things would bother me / And little things would make you cry." This sets up a stark contrast with the present, where a significant breakup is met with an unnerving lack of feeling. The immediate, almost mundane, question about "what do I do with these flowers?" highlights the disorienting aftermath of a relationship's demise.
The central tension arises from the disconnect between the expected emotional fallout of a breakup and the actual void experienced by the narrator and their partner. The narrator confesses "feeling nothing," while observing their partner's inability "to even cry." This emotional numbness is perplexing, especially given their history of being sensitive to "little things." The lyrics suggest a profound disillusionment, questioning the very nature of their past love.
The most striking element is the redefinition of deeply personal, significant items and feelings as mere "sentimental thing[s]." The ring, once a symbol of commitment, becomes something to be questioned in its purpose. Even the narrator's evenings, presumably once filled with shared activities, are now adrift. This phrase, "sentimental thing," is repeated, stripping away its conventional warmth and reducing profound emotional connections to something trivial and easily discarded, especially when contrasted with the earlier "little things" that once held so much weight.
This lyrical approach is effective because it grounds abstract emotional states in concrete, relatable details like flowers and evenings. The shift from past sensitivity to present numbness creates a palpable sense of loss, not of the relationship itself, but of the capacity to feel its ending. The final, almost desperate, questioning of whether love itself was just "another sentimental thing" leaves the listener with a lingering sense of existential doubt about the value of past affections.