Song Meaning
The narrator is captivated by Rita May, but there's a clear disconnect between her physical presence and her inner world. He's drawn to her, admitting "it's your mind that I want," yet feels diminished beside her, "Next to you I feel like nothin'." This initial fascination is tinged with a sense of bewilderment and perhaps a touch of desperation.
The central tension lies in the narrator's inability to fully grasp Rita May's essence. He questions her awareness and emotional state, asking, "When do you ever see the light?" and "Don't you ever feel a fright?" Despite his confusion and the warnings from his friends that associating with her might be detrimental ("That I'll go blind"), he's convinced there's more to her than meets the eye, believing "there really must be somethin' / On your mind."
The lyrics employ a striking metaphor, casting Rita May as a "book of knowledge" that the narrator feels compelled to study, even suggesting he needs to "go to college" to understand her. This elevates her from a mere object of desire to an enigmatic figure whose complexity he is driven to decipher. The repetition of her name, "Rita May, Rita May," acts like a chant, emphasizing his fixation and the almost obsessive nature of his pursuit.
Ultimately, the effectiveness of these lyrics stems from their portrayal of an intense, almost unrequited intellectual and emotional pursuit. The narrator's vulnerability and his willingness to confront his own feelings of inadequacy in the face of Rita May's mystery make the narrative compelling. It captures that specific, frustrating, yet exhilarating moment when someone's presence sparks a deep desire to understand them, even if they remain just out of reach.