Song Meaning
The ensemble paints a cynical picture of male motivation, suggesting grand gestures are always driven by romantic pursuit. Whether reaching for stars or waiting in the rain, the lyrics posit that a man's actions, no matter how extreme, are ultimately for a "doll." This perspective frames male ambition and devotion as inherently transactional, tied to the approval of a specific woman.
The core tension lies in this reductive view of male behavior versus the implied depth of the "doll's" influence. The narrator insists that paying exorbitant rent for a questionable apartment is "better than even money" to be for "some doll." This highlights a perceived irrationality in male devotion, bordering on madness, as described by the "insane as only a John can be for a Jane."
The women's section offers a counterpoint, shifting the focus to the undeniable outward signs of being "in love." The narrator directly addresses someone, asserting that their "eyes are the eyes of a woman in love" and that these expressions "give you away." The repetition of "woman in love" emphasizes the transparency of this emotional state, regardless of attempts to conceal it.
This lyrical construction is effective because it juxtaposes a detached, almost jaded observation of male folly with an intimate, knowing acknowledgment of female emotion. The ensemble's pronouncements feel like a universal, albeit cynical, truth, while the women's lines bring it down to a personal, undeniable reality. The contrast between the broad, sweeping statements about men and the specific, piercing observation about a woman's eyes creates a compelling emotional dynamic.