You say ’tis Love

Song Meaning

These lyrics stage a spirited debate between Philidel and Grimbald, each offering a distinct view on the nature of love. Philidel, wary and cautious, sees love as a source of profound suffering. Grimbald, conversely, is an ardent advocate for love, emphasizing its potential for joy and fulfillment. The central tension arises from Philidel's conviction that love "creates the pain" and brings "wounds of which you die." This perspective frames love as a cruel, ease-robbing force. Grimbald counters, asserting that it's not love itself but "your indifference gives despair," suggesting that love's pain is often a consequence of unreciprocated affection, not an inherent flaw. Grimbald employs a compelling natural metaphor, comparing love to a "lusty Sun" that "begets no Spring / Till gentle show'rs assistance bring." This imagery suggests that love, while powerful, requires kindness and reciprocity to flourish and bring joy, otherwise it "scorches and destroys." His repeated pledge, "I'll be constant, I'll be kind," underscores his commitment to this nurturing vision of love. Ultimately, these lyrics are effective because they capture the timeless push-pull between vulnerability and desire. Philidel's cautionary tales of "floods of tears" are balanced by Grimbald's passionate plea to embrace love before "Age and wisdom comes too fast," culminating in a vision of "faithful Love, and Kind possessing" that promises profound blessing.