WE ARE WATER

Song Meaning

The lyrics present a stark, almost elemental assertion: "We are water." This opening immediately establishes a sense of fluidity, interconnectedness, and perhaps a fundamental, unchangeable nature. It’s a simple statement, yet the questions that follow – about bone strength and holding on – inject a profound vulnerability. The narrator seems to be grappling with the efficacy of this inherent state, questioning if its very essence provides the resilience needed to endure. The central tension arises from the contrast between this fluid identity and the desire for something more solid and enduring, like strong bones. The repeated questioning, "Does it make your bones stay strong?" highlights a deep-seated anxiety about fragility. This is amplified by the stark declaration that "Our bones won't grow in the dirt," a powerful image suggesting that without a proper foundation or environment, growth and strength are impossible, regardless of one's fundamental nature. The phrase "You left the sun" acts as a pivot, introducing a sense of abandonment or loss. The sun, often associated with life, warmth, and growth, is gone. This departure seems to be the catalyst for the narrator's questioning of their watery existence and its ability to sustain them. The relentless repetition of "Our bones won't grow in the dirt" hammers home the feeling of being stuck, unable to flourish in a barren or unfavorable condition, even while acknowledging their fundamental watery being. Ultimately, the effectiveness of these lyrics lies in their raw, almost primal imagery and their direct, unadorned questioning. The repetition creates a sense of insistent worry, while the elemental metaphors of water, bones, sun, and dirt evoke a deep, almost existential unease. It’s a powerful, albeit bleak, meditation on inherent nature versus the need for external conditions to foster strength and growth.