Always Was Sometimes

Song Meaning

The lyrics paint a picture of a past relationship, or perhaps a fleeting intense connection, characterized by a vague but palpable enthusiasm. The repeated phrase "She was so into stuff oh yeah" and "She was really into stuff and things" suggests a vibrant personality, though the specifics remain elusive. This initial impression is amplified by the narrator's own emphasis on how "really really really really really" they both were, hinting at a shared intensity that defies easy definition. The core tension seems to lie in the ephemeral nature of this connection, captured by the central refrain: "Sometimes / Always was sometimes." This phrase is a fascinating twist on expectation, implying that what felt like a constant, an "always," was in reality only present "sometimes." It suggests a perception of permanence that didn't quite align with the actual experience, creating a subtle but profound sense of wistful realization. The true craft here is in the repetition and the almost-non-sequitur phrasing. The excessive "really" and "so" build a sense of overwhelming emotion or experience, but without concrete details, it becomes a feeling of pure, unadulterated *being* together. The juxtaposition of "Sometimes" and "Always" is the linchpin, turning a simple statement of frequency into a poignant commentary on memory and the subjective experience of time within a relationship. This lyrical approach is effective because it mirrors the way intense moments can feel both all-encompassing and fleeting. The vagueness isn't a weakness; it’s the point. It allows the listener to project their own experiences of passionate but perhaps unstable connections onto the narrative, making the emotional core of "Always was sometimes" resonate deeply as a reflection on the nature of intense, imperfectly remembered pasts.