Song Meaning
The lyrics immediately plunge into a deep sense of agitation. The speaker's heart is "restless inside of me," mirroring the vast, unceasing motion of the sea. This isn't just sadness; it's a profound, internal disquiet, fueled by a feeling "I've never known."
This unrest stems from a potent cocktail of regret and self-blame. The speaker obsessively repeats a name "over and over," simultaneously "telling myself I'm to blame." The central conflict emerges in the stark question: "Why did I wait so long / To tell you how I feel?" It reveals a missed opportunity, a moment of hesitation that now haunts them.
The craft here lies in the escalating intensity of the "restless" motif, culminating in a powerful, conditional vow. Initially a simile, "restless as the sea," it transforms into an existential state. The speaker declares, "I'll never rest lest" their love is reciprocated, suggesting that their peace is now entirely contingent on the other person's return. The archaic "lest" lends a solemn, almost fated weight to this promise.
The effectiveness comes from how these lyrics paint a vivid picture of obsessive longing. The constant repetition of "over and over" and the direct, raw interjection "Oh my love" underscore a mind consumed. The speaker isn't just missing someone; they are actively tormented by their absence, their entire being held hostage by a past regret and a desperate future hope.