Song Meaning

The narrator is caught in a classic dilemma, weighing an impulsive, heartfelt desire against more sensible, perhaps parental, advice. The core conflict is laid out starkly: following the heart means love, but following tears means leaving. It’s a direct, almost stark, presentation of two opposing emotional paths. The lyrics introduce a third, more complex option: following the eyes during "crying time." This suggests a path driven by immediate emotional reaction, which the narrator acknowledges will also lead to tears, mirroring the pain of leaving. This isn't a clear escape, but another form of emotional reckoning. The most compelling choice presented is to "follow what Mom says," which promises a state of being "true." This implies a stable, perhaps conventional, relationship, but it’s framed as an external directive rather than an internal desire. The repetition of "We will be true" underscores the certainty of this path, yet its origin outside the narrator’s immediate feelings creates an underlying tension. This song resonates because it captures that universal moment of indecision. The simple, direct language makes the emotional stakes incredibly clear, forcing the listener to consider which internal compass—heart, tears, or external guidance—ultimately dictates our choices and their consequences.