Song Meaning
The lyrics paint a stark picture of post-relationship desolation, where the present is defined by absence and lingering negativity. The repeated "Hold on" acts as a desperate anchor, but each subsequent line reveals the emptiness of what remains: the "void from the things that we had," the "shit that you say when you're mad," and "regrets from our plans put in motion." Even the "feeling I get from the ocean" is framed as a somber echo of what was lost, not a source of solace. The narrator is stuck in the debris of a failed connection.
The central tension lies in the contrast between past ambition and present failure. The memory of fighting for "Back Bay bars" suggests a shared struggle and a desire for something significant, only to have it dissolve into "separate cars." This divergence highlights a profound sense of what-ifs, a feeling that the potential for a shared future was squandered. The narrator laments, "I feel like we could have it all / If we could keep it together," underscoring the fragility of their bond and the immense loss that resulted from its collapse.
The most striking image is the concept of "the left-handed way up to God." This unconventional, perhaps even unorthodox, path suggests a rejection of traditional or expected routes to fulfillment or spiritual connection. It implies that the narrator believes a different, less conventional approach – perhaps one that embraces imperfection or acknowledges the messy reality of their situation – might be more authentic or even more effective than the standard way. It’s a subtle but powerful assertion of individuality in the face of overwhelming regret.
This lyrical construction is effective because it grounds abstract feelings of loss in concrete, albeit brief, images and a unique metaphorical concept. The repetition of "Hold on" creates a sense of immediate, almost panicked, reflection, while the juxtaposition of past aspirations with present emptiness makes the regret palpable. The final, enigmatic line offers a glimmer of a personal philosophy born from hardship, suggesting that even in ruin, there's a unique perspective worth holding onto.