Song Meaning
These lyrics open with a cosmic sense of connection, picturing "Me and you / Two planets spinning 'round." But this initial romantic image quickly gives way to a skewed reality, where "The moon rose is a red / His violets are blue," suggesting a world turned upside down by a relationship's end. There's a wistful longing, a speaker who's "infatuating" and misses someone deeply, yet also seems to know the separation won't last forever.
The emotional core of the lyrics lies in the crushing weight of broken promises. The speaker recalls a time "Back when Pluto was a planet," a nostalgic marker for a simpler, more stable past, contrasting sharply with the present instability. The repeated lament, "You were supposed to love me / You were supposed to protect me, babe," hammers home the profound betrayal, revealing a deep chasm between expectation and reality.
What truly stings is the chilling irony in the ex-partner's actions. The line "You were so professional with it" is a gut punch, describing the cold, efficient manner in which the speaker's heart was broken. This is compounded by the ex's seemingly self-serving piety: "You were so confessional when you did it / Spoke to God and you'll be forgiven." It suggests a detachment, where the ex seeks divine absolution while the speaker is left to grapple with the immediate, raw pain.
Yet, the lyrics conclude with a powerful, repeated declaration: "I forgive you." This isn't a simple act of letting go; it feels like a hard-won peace, a deliberate choice to release the burden of resentment. The repetition suggests a ritual, perhaps a necessary step for the speaker to move forward, reclaiming agency in the face of profound hurt and disillusionment. It's a complex, human response to a deeply personal betrayal.