I Should Be Sleeping

Song Meaning

The lyrics paint a picture of restless nights, filled with late-night TV and pizza. The speaker is wide awake, despite knowing they "should be sleeping." This isn't anxiety, though; it's a giddy, almost disorienting infatuation. The core tension lies in the speaker's internal conflict: a rational awareness of needing sleep versus the overwhelming pull of new romance. They're "pacing and retracing" every moment, caught in a loop of reliving recent interactions. This sleeplessness isn't a burden, but a side effect of feeling "so right" and "so happy," creating a charming paradox. A key craft element is the contrast between the speaker's past self and their current state. They admit, "I've never been a real night owl," and never liked being called "honey." Yet, this new person has fundamentally shifted their habits and even their self-perception, making them feel "all turned around" in a delightful way. The lyrics suggest this new connection is revealing previously unknown aspects of their personality. The lyrics effectively capture the disorienting, all-consuming nature of early infatuation. The speaker's self-awareness, particularly in acknowledging "it's way too soon" to be obsessing, grounds the intense emotion in a relatable, almost humorous honesty. This blend of giddy joy, sleepless nights, and a touch of self-deprecating humor makes the experience feel authentic and deeply human.