Song Meaning
Diane Schuur's rendition of "It Had to Be You" isn't just a simple declaration of love; it's a complex ode to the imperfections that bind us. The song's central thesis revolves around the acceptance, even the celebration, of a lover's flaws. It acknowledges that other potential partners might be 'nicer' or 'easier,' yet they lack the essential spark—that unique 'thrill'—that makes the relationship with the chosen one irreplaceable. This speaks to a deeper psychological truth: we often crave not perfection, but authenticity, even when that authenticity manifests as occasional 'blues' or 'sadness.'
The lyrics subtly dissect the listener's romantic expectations. Schuur isn't just singing about settling for someone; she's articulating a conscious choice to embrace the full spectrum of a person, the good and the bad. The repetition of 'It had to be you' underscores the idea of inevitability, suggesting that the connection transcends mere compatibility. It touches upon the idea that true love isn't about finding someone who avoids conflict ('never be mean, might never be cross'), but rather someone whose very being resonates with yours, flaws and all.
Ultimately, the enduring appeal of "It Had to Be You," especially as interpreted by Diane Schuur, lies in its raw honesty. It's a refreshing counterpoint to the often-idealized portrayals of love in popular culture. The 'faults' are not glossed over; they're integrated into the very fabric of the affection. This isn't blind devotion; it's a clear-eyed acknowledgment of human complexity, a recognition that the things that irritate us can also be the things we cherish most. The song's meaning becomes a testament to the power of accepting a partner as a whole, imperfect being, and finding joy in the uniquely flawed connection you share.
