Song Meaning

The lyrics plunge us into a surreal scene: "all the girls in the world" are inexplicably following the narrator. He's treated "as if I were the Messiah," a claim he insists upon to the listener. This immediate, almost dreamlike devotion sets a bizarre tone. Initially, the narrator basks in this inexplicable attention, admitting he was "drinking buttermilk" – a French idiom for loving it. Yet, this pleasure is tinged with confusion, as he repeatedly asks, "What's gotten into them?" and "What do I do with them?" This tension between flattered ego and genuine bewilderment drives the first half of the narrative. The narrative takes a sharp, ironic turn in the second stanza, as the narrator asserts, "I held them at my mercy." He then leads these followers to "paradise," only to abruptly declare, "It's here that all the Eves clear out!" This dramatic expulsion, casting the girls as "little criminals," cleverly subverts the biblical Eden story, with the narrator playing a dismissive Adam. These lyrics are effective because they blend surreal fantasy with a cynical commentary on adoration and power. The narrator's shift from bewildered recipient to authoritative expeller creates a compelling, unsettling dynamic. By twisting familiar archetypes, the song leaves the listener with a provocative image of fleeting influence and perhaps a darker take on the allure of a charismatic figure.