Song Meaning
The lyrics paint a picture of youthful romantic idealism clashing with the sober reality of life's unfolding narrative. The narrator recalls being "romantic / And young and stupid," meeting her husband with a naive certainty about how things "go." This initial perspective is characterized by a belief in personal agency and a predictable plot, where "You think you know the story" and anticipate a "happy ending." This youthful certainty is directly contrasted with the later realization that "you don't know the story."
The central tension arises from this shift in perspective, moving from a self-centered, cinematic view of life to a more resigned acceptance. The spoken interlude, with its question about a "wife" waiting in Egypt, hints at the complexities and potential disappointments in relationships and personal histories that defy simple narratives. The narrator's subsequent lines, "Ahh, but then you see it / You learn your lesson / Grow up a little," mark the transition to a more mature, albeit less optimistic, outlook.
The most striking aspect of the writing is the stark simplicity of the titular phrase, "Then it is what it is." This phrase acts as a pivot point, encapsulating the resignation that follows the dashed expectations of youth. It's a quiet admission of powerlessness against the currents of life, a settling into a state of "what you got" after the "blah, blah, blah" of grander plans fades. The repetition of "You think you know" underscores the futility of trying to control or predict the future.
This lyrical arc is effective because it taps into a universal experience of disillusionment and adaptation. The contrast between the initial, almost arrogant, belief in knowing the story and the final, quiet acceptance of "it is what it is" resonates deeply. It’s a poignant, understated acknowledgment that life rarely adheres to our meticulously crafted scripts, and sometimes, the most profound wisdom comes from letting go of the illusion of control.