It Was There (That I Saw You)

Song Meaning

These lyrics open with a vivid, almost cinematic memory: "It was there that I saw you." The setting is a specific place, imbued with significance, as "evening sighs" against the skyline. This initial scene quickly gives way to a lingering question, hinting at a past connection that has since fractured. The central tension emerges from a stark contrast between a vibrant past and a confused present. The narrator recalls a person who was "fair and fey as a sun that evil day," a striking juxtaposition of enchanting beauty with an ominous undertone. This memory of a time when "we were bold and life was great" is immediately undercut by the present's persistent query: "I wondered what went wrong." A series of pleas, starting with "Let me hold you in my arms dear," reveals a deep yearning to return to or surrender to that past intimacy. The desire to "melt in the heat of your gaze" and "let our sense of selves decay" suggests an almost desperate wish to lose oneself entirely in the memory or the person, escaping the present's uncertainty. It's a powerful, almost unsettling image of dissolution. The lyrics circle back to the original memory, intensifying the unresolved question. The repetition of "Became, became, became, became, became / Of you" isn't just a question; it's an echo, a haunting refrain that emphasizes the narrator's obsession with what was lost or transformed. This insistent repetition captures the persistent, unanswered nature of their longing, leaving the listener with a profound sense of wistful regret.