Song Meaning
The lyrics paint a picture of a deeply cherished past, a time of pure love and shared dreams. The opening lines establish a sense of distance, both in time and space, from a foundational moment where "two hearts in love" existed under "stars above." This initial setting feels almost mythical, a perfect, perhaps idealized, memory that the narrator longs to revisit. The phrase "make believe" hints that this golden era might have been a fantasy, or at least a time when reality felt less important than their shared affection.
The central tension lies in the narrator's yearning to recapture that past. The recurring invitation, "Come sail away," acts as a plea to return to those "golden days." This sailing isn't literal travel but a metaphorical journey across the "sea of memories." The narrator is caught between the present, where the sun sets "low upon the bay," and the vivid recollection of a time when their love felt so potent it could "teach the stars to shine."
The most striking craft element is the persistent, almost hypnotic repetition of "Come sail away." This refrain functions as both an invitation and a desperate wish, a constant echo of the desire to escape the present and return to a more perfect time. The contrast between the "so long ago" and "now and then I sail again" highlights the cyclical nature of memory and longing, suggesting that while the past is gone, its pull remains incredibly strong. The lyrics also subtly shift from a shared past to a direct address, "So come my love, let love be true, remember me," grounding the abstract longing in a present plea for reciprocation.
Ultimately, the effectiveness of these lyrics stems from their simple, direct expression of nostalgia and enduring love. By focusing on evocative, yet general, imagery like "stars above" and "golden days," the words tap into a universal feeling of looking back at a cherished relationship. The gentle, almost lullaby-like rhythm implied by the phrasing creates a comforting yet melancholic atmosphere, making the desire to "sail away" feel both understandable and deeply poignant.