Lyrics

[Verse 1] Dear Natalie Let me guess, he's still mad at me Probably saying that I lied That I'm crazy, I'm off the deep end But did you ever think maybe He seemed a little too shady? [Chorus] 'Cause he said, "Forever, I'm yours" But he probably said it to me and to you and to her It started off so good, with every word, he swore he wouldn't But I was never the only one And I'm sure I could never be Natalie [Verse 2] Owen told me Do you still wear that dress hе likes? The one you worе on that Friday night When you were talking, I was watching And crying in the corner But it didn't matter (It didn't matter) [Chorus] 'Cause he said, "Forever, I'm yours" But he probably said it to me and to you and to her It started off so good, with every word, he swore he wouldn't But I was never the only one And I'm sure I could never be Natalie [Bridge] Oh, Natalie I still lie awake from his apathy How he dared to have the audacity To hold my hand while wrecking your plans But did you ever think maybe I'm not the girl that he made me? [Chorus] 'Cause he said, "Forever, I'm yours" But he probably said it to me and to you and to her It started off so good, with every word, he swore he wouldn't But I was never the only one And I'm sure I could never be Natalie [Outro] No, I could never be