The Papers And Writings Of Abraham Lincoln-VOL. VII (Chap. 3.58)

Song Meaning

This brief telegram from A. Lincoln to Major-General Pope immediately establishes a scene of wartime communication, direct and urgent. Lincoln is inquiring about a specific bureaucratic issue: property assessments in St. Louis County. The tone is formal yet carries a distinct undercurrent of concern for an individual. The central tension arises from Lincoln's clear stance on the matter versus his request for Pope's opinion. He presents a case for Samuel B. Churchill, stating he has "satisfactory evidence that he has not misbehaved." This suggests a leader personally invested in ensuring fair treatment, even amidst the larger conflicts of the war. The craft here lies in Lincoln's subtle yet firm persuasion. He first establishes Churchill's good conduct, then directly states his belief that the property "ought not to be" subjected to assessment. This builds a strong argument before the concluding phrase, "Still I wish to know what you think." This final line, while appearing to invite input, actually frames the request within Lincoln's already articulated conviction. These lyrics are effective because they reveal a nuanced exercise of authority. Lincoln isn't just issuing an order; he's presenting a reasoned argument, backed by his own investigation, while still formally seeking counsel. It paints a picture of a leader who is both decisive in his judgment and strategically diplomatic in his communication, aiming to guide the outcome rather than simply dictate it.