The Papers And Writings Of Abraham Lincoln-VOL. V (Chap. 1.2)

Song Meaning

This is a direct, almost curt, response to a political attack, likely from a newspaper called the "Times." Lincoln, writing from Springfield in 1858, addresses H. C. Whitney, who seems to have forwarded the criticism. The immediate tone is one of dismissive confidence, suggesting the accusation is baseless and easily refuted. The central tension lies in the contrast between the public "attack" and Lincoln's private, measured response. He assures Whitney not to worry, implying a belief in the power of truth to overcome falsehood. However, he explicitly states he will *not* publish his rebuttal, preferring a more targeted approach, perhaps through private channels or by letting the contradiction speak for itself without amplifying the original charge. The craft here is in the understated authority. Phrases like "Give yourself no concern" and "there is not a word of truth in the charge" convey a quiet certainty. The instruction "Show this to whomever you please, but do not publish it in the paper" highlights a strategic, behind-the-scenes approach to managing public perception, prioritizing direct communication over public spectacle. What makes these lyrics effective is their glimpse into a political mind at work. It's not about grand pronouncements but about the practical, strategic maneuvering required to counter criticism. The efficiency of the language, devoid of emotional outbursts, underscores a pragmatic confidence in his own position and the eventual triumph of fact over falsehood.